WHO SAVED PARIS CITY FROM COMPLETE DESTRUCTION IN SECOND WORLD WAR
"Aey shahr tera naam-o-nishaan bhi nahin hota,
Jo haadse hone thay agar ho gaye hotay.."
(O city, not even your name would remain,
If the disasters that were meant to happen
had actually happened.)
For years I laboured under the misapprehension that, during the Second World War, Adolf Hitler had issued explicit instructions to his troops to leave Paris’s historic monuments and cultural sites untouched, as though the city’s incomparable beauty had somehow secured it a special dispensation. That comforting notion, repeated in popular histories and casual conversation alike until it acquired the weight of fact, was thoroughly dispelled during my present stay in the city. A careful examination of archival material in the Archives Nationales, war-time correspondence preserved at the Musée de la Libération, and the meticulous catalogues of the ERR at the Jeu de Paume revealed a far starker reality. Far from safeguarding Paris, the Nazi regime systematically looted its private collections on a staggering scale, converted the Palais Bourbon and other palaces into Luftwaffe and Wehrmacht headquarters, and by the summer of 1944 had wired the Seine’s bridges, Notre-Dame, Les Invalides and the Eiffel Tower with explosives. Hitler’s directive to General Dietrich von Choltitz in August of that year was unequivocal: : “Paris darf nicht oder nur als Trümmerfeld in die Hand des Feindes fallen” , the capital was not to fall into Allied hands except as a field of ruins. That Paris endures today, its skyline and stone still largely intact, owes nothing to restraint on Hitler’s part. It owes instead to a confluence of resistance, negotiation and, ultimately, one general’s refusal to ignite the fuses.
In August 1944, as Allied forces advanced on the French capital, Adolf Hitler issued repeated and explicit orders to destroy Paris. Early that month he commanded General Dietrich von Choltitz, the German military governor, to “stamp out” any insurrection “without pity” and to demolish the city’s waterworks, power stations and dozens of historic bridges across the Seine, including the centuries-old Pont Neuf and the Pont Alexandre III. On 20 August he demanded “the widest destruction possible”. Three days later, on 23 August, the order became absolute. Hitler cabled von Choltitz: “Paris must not fall into the hands of the enemy, or, if it does, he must find there nothing but a field of ruins”. He later asked his staff the infamous question, “Is Paris burning?” German engineers carried out the groundwork. Explosives were laid beneath every bridge across the Seine, at the base of the Eiffel Tower, in the crypts of Notre Dame, inside the Louvre, at the Palais Garnier and other monuments that defined the city’s cultural identity. The aim was not only military denial but the erasure of Paris as a symbol.
Yet Paris was spared. The man who disobeyed was General Dietrich von Choltitz. An aristocratic Prussian officer who took command of the city on 7 August 1944, he received Hitler’s demolition orders but refused to execute them. By his later account, he judged the destruction militarily futile. He had insufficient troops to hold Paris against Allied armour, and razing the capital would not change the outcome of the war. He also professed an “affection for the French capital’s history and culture”, calling the order “medieval” while looking out from his headquarters over the Tuileries, Place de la Concorde and the Louvre. Other historians note that the Parisian Resistance had risen on 19 August, and by late August von Choltitz had little practical control of the city. The speed of the Allied advance meant full demolition was likely impossible even had he wished to comply. One account credits Swedish Consul-General Raoul Nordling with appealing to his legacy, asking whether he wanted to be remembered as the man who destroyed Paris or the man who saved it. Whatever the decisive factor, von Choltitz kept Hitler’s order in his pocket and showed it to no subordinate.
On 25 August 1944, with Colonel Henri Rol-Tanguy’s Resistance fighters in control of key buildings and General Philippe Leclerc de Hauteclocque’s 2nd French Armoured Division entering the city, von Choltitz surrendered the German garrison at the Préfecture de Police on the Île de la Cité. He signed the terms of capitulation, ending four years of Nazi occupation. The charges under Paris’ bridges and landmarks were never detonated. For this, von Choltitz later became known, with some controversy, as the “Saviour of Paris”. Hitler, enraged, branded him a traitor and demanded his execution.
The significance of that decision was formally recognised 60 years later. On 25 August 2004, French President Jacques Chirac unveiled a commemorative plaque at the Préfecture de Police de Paris to mark the 60th anniversary of von Choltitz’s surrender. The tablet honours the moment Dietrich von Choltitz signed the terms of capitulation, ending the occupation. By choosing the Préfecture as the site, the ceremony tied two things together: the military liberation of the city and the survival of its bridges, monuments and cultural heritage. Though von Choltitz’s motives remain debated by historians, the commemoration positioned his refusal to execute Hitler’s “field of ruins” order as integral to the Liberation itself.
So who saved Paris in the Second World War? It was not one man alone. The French Resistance who rose against the occupiers, the Free French and Allied troops who fought into the city, and the Parisians who refused to yield all played their part. But the reason the Louvre, Notre Dame, and the Eiffel Tower still stand is because one German general disobeyed a direct order from Hitler. The plaque at the Préfecture de Police remains a reminder that 25 August marks not only the end of occupation, but the day Paris was spared from planned demolition.
( Avtar Mota )
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.