“Anybody don’t like ice . Ice is heating ” Aziz had said when Sir V S Naipaul had asked for some ice to be made available to him in the Hotel room .Kashmiris continue to have their strange notions about heat and cold in the human body. Most often they still say “ Me Gondun Naar ” when they take spicy foods or miss their daily dose of Curd . I remember elders telling youngsters in Kashmir that Ice cream is just fire when it goes inside human body.
“You Buy , I buy – what difference ? ”Aziz had said when Naipaul had asked for the change of electric bulb in the hotel Room. This is a graceful way of saying No . It is still practised . It is practised by my own friends .Muslims and Pandits would say No tactfully in this way only . You would never get a straight NO generally . Even for something which a person could never do, his stock reply was “ Kenh Naa Chhunaa Baa Vuchhaa Telli ” Meaning Don’t worry . Let me see what can be done .
“He Not Tourist ”This is how Aziz had intervened and rebuked a local Tonga wallah who had overcharged Naipaul. This is still true in Kashmir . People still cry when they feel that they are being overcharged “ Ba Naa Chhuss Naa Tourist” Meaning I am Not a Tourist .
“Hadn’t we better find out about the times of Gulmarg Buses Aziz ” Naipaul had said when he planned to visit Gulmarg with Aziz. “ O No Sahib Too Much Bus ” Aziz had replied back..When they went to the Bus stand , they came to know that the 8 O’ clock bus had been missed.The next bus was at 12 Noon . They had to wait at the Bus Stand for four hours .This used to be the way of taking things casually in Kashmir . This has undergone sea change. People are serious about everything now. Previously When People( Both Pandits and Muslims ) would take serious issues casually ,they did say “ Kenh Chhnnaa Parvaay, Maa hey Fikir . ” Meaning there is no need to worry .
“He have wife . He have children . He poor man sahib . You Not report Tourism Sahib . He not honest man but he poor .” Aziz telling Naipaul
.“I am Best sportsman . I am best swimmer . I know all Physics and all chemistry ” This is how a college student had introduced himself to Naipaul in his hotel room .
These are some incidents mentioned in Area of Darkness written by Nobel Laureate Sir V S Naipaul.. Sir V S Naipaul is a writer of Indian origin from Trinidad. Born in 1932, he started writing in english from 1950. Some of his books which i have enjoyed reading are :-
1 A House for Mr Biswas .
2 A Flag on the Island ( Especially stories like The enemy and Night watchman's occurrence book )
3 Letters Between Father and son.
4 Area of Darkness
5 Half a life .
I also like Late shiva Naipaul's ( His real Brother also a writer ) style . Shiva ( 1945 - 1985 ) died young of a heart attack.I enjoyed Shiva's book , Beyond the Dragon's Mouth: Stories and Pieces.
Those of us who have lived in kashmir and more particularly known people living in Dal Lake area connected with Tourism Industry or are privy to their trade practices shall better understand the humor and wit put forth by Naipaul in the entire Part II of the book devoted to Kashmir only.. Naipaul has the unique quality of making his characters reveal all by themselves .The travaelogue is superb and absorbing.There are many instances in the Travelogue which demonstrate exceptional observation of events and characters by Naipaul .Naipaul has devoted more than 125 pages of this travelogue to Kashmir alone .
Naipaul stayed in Kashmir for about 5 months in 1962. . This popular and widely read Travelogue was written in Hotel Liward Dal lake Srinagar .Naipaul went for his Amarnath Yatra with Hotel’s main Attendent Aziz and the cook Ali Mohd . Aziz has been presented as a typical Lake dweller who speaks English learnt from Guests and who has his own set notions about all issues around him. These notions have been built partly on account of his upbringing and partly contrived by him through his interaction with tourists. Still Aziz remains essentially a kashmiri and a simple Human being . If the writer could not ignore him, no reader can ignore him either . You may see through Aziz’s funny intrigues in the Hotel Kitchen or garden but these are primarily aimed to supplement his meagre income to feed his family back home.. It is easy for any reader to identify with this man.
Naipaul stayed in Kashmir for about 5 months in 1962. . This popular and widely read Travelogue was written in Hotel Liward Dal lake Srinagar .Naipaul went for his Amarnath Yatra with Hotel’s main Attendent Aziz and the cook Ali Mohd . Aziz has been presented as a typical Lake dweller who speaks English learnt from Guests and who has his own set notions about all issues around him. These notions have been built partly on account of his upbringing and partly contrived by him through his interaction with tourists. Still Aziz remains essentially a kashmiri and a simple Human being . If the writer could not ignore him, no reader can ignore him either . You may see through Aziz’s funny intrigues in the Hotel Kitchen or garden but these are primarily aimed to supplement his meagre income to feed his family back home.. It is easy for any reader to identify with this man.
Naipaul called this Hotel a DOLL”S HOUSE . Names like Mohd sidiq Bhat , Aziz , Ali Mohd , Mr Madan and Mr Kak referred to by him in this book are not fictional characters . They all existed in Bones and flesh . Some of them still continue their struggle in the changed environs and circumstances. I Happened to Know Mr Kak ( S. K Kak IAS Ex Director of Tourism and controller of Tawaza J&;K ). Late kak Sahib had confirmed having seen Naipaul twice .Mr Madan was also a senior officer in Tourism department and senior to kak sahib . Mr Mohd sidiq Bhat was the owner of Hotel Liward when Naipaul Stayed over there . The name of the hotel was changed to LEEWARD later . Aziz who was the senior Attendent with Mr Bhat in 1962 later became the owner of the Hotel . Aziz of Area of Darkness is actually Abdul Aziz who still lives in the lake ;An old and affectionate man who vividly remembers Naipaul and the introductory letter he wrote for Hotel’s permit from Tourism department . The Hotel has since added more rooms from bare 7 rooms it had when Naipaul stayed .The Hotel is just 5 minutes Shikara ride from Nehru Park Ghats on the Boulevard .One can locate it exactly at the back of Nehru park. A beautiful Lotus Garden spread over lake water surface has been developed behind the Hotel. Abdul Aziz's Leeward Hotel has been occupied by security forces at present .
“ What rent Government pays? . Just 170 Rupee per day per room .75% of this amount is spent for the maintenance of the Hotel. Jenab Many visitors would came here in good old days just to see where Naipaul sahib stayed . They wrote comments in visitor book. ”says Abdul Aziz
Apart from being a finest travelogue , Area of Darkness also opens Kashmir of 1962 to the world . But Yes a Kashmir seen only around Dal Lake or tourist places like Gulmarg , Pahalgham , Bund , Lal Chowk , Tourist centre and Nageen lake mostly . This brilliant narrative is Surprisingly silent about other Kashmir which was throbbing with activity in Naipaul’s close vicinity . By other kashmir i mean the Artists , saints , Reshis , Artisans and Craftsmen( engaged in Papier mache , Wood carving and handicrafts manufacturing with their gifted hands ) , Politicians , intellectuals , Prominent Khankaahs , Ziyarats, Temples and historical buildings of the city deserved some mention in this travelogue .People ( Both Muslims and Pandits ) living in Down town areas like Zainakaal , Fateh Kadal ,Habba kadal , Naid kadal , Saraf Kadal, Nowhatta , Bohri Kadal , Zadibal , Khanyar or in the newer Colonies of that period like Karan Nagar ,Jawahir Nagar and Raj Bagh find no mention in this Book . Inspite of these minor issues which only a kashmiri reader can observe , Area of Darkness remains a brilliant narrative and makes you to travel all the places and share the events together with Sir V S Naipaul. Area of Darkness presents Naipaul not only as an innovative writer of a superior class but his ideas too are truly creative , original and bright.
Naipaul again visited kashmir in 1989 and covered the visit in his book India :A Million Mutinies. This time the critical assessment of the land , its people and their Habits had mellowed down considerably. In this book , Naipaul is all praise for a resurgent and developing India . He again talks about Kashmir . For him Kashmir had changed a lot . But then the explosions and first gunfires of the two decade old trouble had begun. He mentions these incidents also .So Long so much..I wish Naipaul good health and happiness .
CHINAR SHADE by Autarmota is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 India License.
Based on a work at http:\\autarmota.blogspot.com\.





Mota sahib,
ReplyDeleteYou have read Naipaul extensively and are in a commanding position to elaborate upon his works. I am in full agreement with your views. That simplicity and innocence amongst the kashmiri folk is now missing. May be this is a fallout of development, progress.
yes sir , Development has a cost.
ReplyDelete